The essentials at a glance
- Under Section 630e of the German Civil Code (BGB), patients must be informed verbally before treatment – via video consultation or, in simple cases, by phone, but never through a consent form alone.
- Digital consent forms and electronic signatures are permitted and carry the same evidential value in court as paper forms: they count as circumstantial evidence, which becomes stronger the more individually the consent discussion is documented.
- AI may prepare, summarise and document the consent process, but it cannot replace the consent discussion itself – responsibility remains with you as the practitioner.
What is the legal basis for informed consent discussions?
The duty to inform patients is set out in Section 630e BGB and applies to every medical and dental practice – regardless of whether you support the process on paper or digitally.
Section 630e (1) sentence 1 BGB obliges practitioners to inform patients about all circumstances that are essential for their consent to medical treatment. These include in particular – but not exclusively:
- type
- scope
- procedure
- expected consequences and risks of the measure
- its necessity
- urgency
- suitability
- prospects of success with regard to diagnosis or treatment
You must also point out alternatives if several equally indicated and common methods can lead to significantly different burdens, risks or chances of recovery (Section 630e (1) sentence 3 BGB). In dentistry, this applies for example to the choice between an implant, a bridge and removable dentures.
Why do patients need to be informed?
Informed consent protects your patients' right to self-determination: only someone who knows the risks, opportunities and alternatives can give effective consent to treatment.
Within the framework of constitutional and other fundamental values of the legal system, every individual should be able to decide freely about their own body and what happens to it.
It is therefore up to the patient whether they want to be treated and which risks and opportunities of the available alternative therapies they choose.
Without proper information, consent is invalid (Section 630d (2) BGB). Medically, you may have done everything right. Legally, the treatment can still be challenged.
Who may inform the patient, and how?
Under Section 630e (2) BGB, the patient may be informed by the treating practitioner or by a person who has the training required to carry out the measure.
For your dental practice, this means: informing patients about the risks and alternatives of a dental procedure is a dentist's job. The conversation can also be held by a colleague who will not perform the procedure themselves. Your dental assistant can prepare the conversation, explain documents and be present as a witness.
From a formal point of view, the law sets several requirements:
- The patient must be informed verbally. The conversation does not necessarily have to take place in person – what matters is a direct verbal exchange in which the patient can ask questions.
- It must take place before the specific treatment, and early enough for the patient to weigh up the pros and cons. Apart from emergencies and special situations, the patient must be given a period for reflection that is appropriate to the significance of the procedure.
- The information must be understandable in language and content for the individual patient.
Is informing patients by video or phone permitted?
Yes, under certain conditions. As early as 2010, the German Federal Court of Justice (BGH) ruled that in simple cases, patients can also be informed by phone (BGH, judgment of 15 June 2010 – VI ZR 204/09). For video consultations, the German legislator clarified in 2019 that informing patients via telecommunication is already permitted under current law, as long as a direct verbal exchange between you and the patient is possible.

When you inform patients remotely, document particularly carefully how, when and about what you spoke.
Which documents are required for informed consent?
Consent forms are not required by law, but they are strongly recommended in practice for evidential reasons.
Using accompanying documents during the consent discussion, such as consent forms, is not required by law. However, such documents can make the information easier for the patient to understand and are therefore commonly used in practice.
It has also proven useful to record the content of the consent discussion and have the patient sign it afterwards, as protection against possible medical liability claims, so that you can prove proper information in any liability proceedings.
Two points are binding:
- Copy for the patient: You must hand the patient copies of any documents they signed in connection with the information or consent (Section 630e (2) sentence 2 BGB).
- Cost information in text form: If you know that the costs will not be fully covered by the statutory health insurance – for example for private services or the patient's share of the cost of dentures – you must inform your patients in text form about the expected costs before treatment begins (Section 630c (3) BGB). Text form means that an email or a digital document is sufficient.
Is digital informed consent permitted?
The law does not set any formal requirements for documents used to inform patients. A consent form therefore does not have to exist on paper or be signed by hand. The law explicitly refers to documents that the patient receives in text form – digital documents meet this requirement.
You can provide the copy digitally, for example by email or via a patient portal. Since the law does not explicitly regulate digital handover, you should also offer a paper version on request.
Digital support for informed consent, as well as digital documentation and signing, are therefore permitted – provided the verbal consent discussion takes place.
What is the evidential value of digital consent documents?
A digitally signed consent form has the same evidential value in court as a paper form – no more, but no less.
In the event of a liability claim, you must prove that you informed the patient properly (Section 630h (2) BGB). However, a signed form does not prove that the patient read and understood it or that a conversation took place. The courts treat it as circumstantial evidence of a consent discussion (BGH, NJW 2014, 1527).
Digital forms signed on a tablet or signature pad have a special legal status: they are not a document in the legal sense (Urkunde), but an object of visual inspection (Section 371 of the German Code of Civil Procedure, ZPO). The court assesses them freely – just as it assesses a paper form as circumstantial evidence. As early as 2013, Spickhoff and Bleckwenn concluded that an electronically signed consent form secured against subsequent changes has no lower evidential value than a handwritten one (VersR 2013, 1350). Current legal literature confirms this equivalence.

So what matters is not the medium but individualisation. The more specifically a form is tailored to the patient and supplemented with personal notes, the stronger it is as evidence. A standard form with no reference to the specific tooth, material or findings will do little for you if it comes to a dispute.
You can read about the rules of evidence that apply when a patient accuses you of a treatment error in our article Accused of a treatment error: How does your documentation protect you?
What role will AI play in the future of informed consent?
Artificial intelligence can prepare the consent process, make it easier to understand and document it – but under current law, it does not replace your verbal consent discussion.
Digital signatures have long been part of everyday life in many practices. The next step is AI assistants that document conversations or translate treatment plans into plain language. This raises a new question for your consent process: what can AI take over – and what not?
Can AI replace the consent discussion?
No. Section 630e BGB requires a conversation with the treating practitioner or a person with the necessary training. An AI is not such a person – legal literature also points out that it lacks legal capacity (Katzenmeier, MedR 2021, 859). Even an AI chatbot that answers patients' questions about a procedure can at most supplement your conversation.
If you use AI directly in the consent process, for example as an interactive information service, legal literature also calls for a separate notice to the patient – combined with their explicit consent to this form of support (Voigt, in: BeckOGK BGB, Section 823 para. 1088).
Where does AI usefully support informed consent?
Wherever your patients need information that should be available beyond the conversation:
- Preparation: Patients receive an easy-to-understand summary of their treatment before the appointment. They know what to expect and bring their questions straight into the consultation.
- Comprehensibility: AI translates technical terms from the treatment plan into patient-friendly, everyday language. This supports the legal requirement to inform patients in an understandable way.
- Time to reflect: Patients can read through the plan at home in peace instead of deciding under time pressure in the treatment room. This strengthens the free decision-making the law requires.
You remain responsible for every AI-generated summary. Always review it before your patients receive it.
This is exactly where Nelly's AI Treatment Plan Agent comes in: it automatically creates an easy-to-understand summary of every treatment plan so that your patients can better follow the planned treatment. They then sign the plan digitally and choose their preferred payment method straight away.
Learn more here: https://www.getnelly.de/en/ai-assistance#ki-plan-agent
How does AI help document the consent discussion?
In court, what counts is what was discussed in the conversation. Yet this is often the most poorly documented part. Liability proceedings often begin years after treatment – by then, nobody remembers exactly what was said.
Nelly's AI Documentation automatically creates the documentation of your treatment from a voice recording. You review and confirm the result before it is transferred. The AI identifies relevant content and discards everything else – it does not make any medical assessment.
If the consent discussion is recorded with Nelly's AI Documentation, the risks and treatment alternatives discussed can also be documented. If the patient's voice is included, medically relevant questions from the patient can be taken into account as well. Inform your patients transparently about the recording in advance and obtain their consent before you start. Afterwards, check the documentation for accuracy and completeness.
“The Nelly AI is worth its weight in gold for us, because it takes routine tasks off our hands in the treatment room. As a result, our documentation and billing are perfect.”
– Dr Tim Graf, ZÄHNE

Learn more here: https://www.getnelly.de/en/ai-assistance#ki-dokumentation
Do you have to tell patients that you use AI?
Since August 2026, the transparency obligations of the EU AI Act (Article 50) have applied. If patients communicate directly with an AI system – for example a chatbot on your website or in the patient portal – it must be clear to them that they are interacting with an AI.
If you use AI in the background, for example for documentation, the information obligations under data protection law are what mainly apply: your patients must know which data is processed and for what purpose.
Digital consent forms from Nelly
Nelly offers your practice digital consent forms. Your benefits:
- Maximum customisation: Design your consent forms quickly and intuitively. Whether it is the material, the affected region or a specific tooth – you decide what is relevant. This also strengthens individualisation and with it the evidential value of your consent documentation.
- Clear and transparent preview: Before final approval, you and your patients can review the forms in a clear preview.
- Digital efficiency: All relevant information, such as the time of the procedure, how it is carried out and medical notes, is recorded digitally and can be accessed at any time.
- Better patient experience: Together with your patients, you can go through and explain every aspect of the treatment digitally – from side effects to rules of conduct before and after the procedure.
- Seamless communication: With just one click, the forms can be sent to the patient by SMS or email.
- Easy access for everyone: The documents can be viewed at any time via both the doctor portal and the patient portal – so the copy for your patients is automatically available.
Learn more here: https://www.getnelly.de/en/patient-intake#digitale-dokumente
Conclusion: Digital informed consent takes the load off your practice – the conversation stays yours
Digital support for informed consent is permitted, legally compliant and noticeably reduces paperwork in your practice. Digital forms have the same evidential value as paper – what matters is that you inform each patient individually and document the conversation in a traceable way. AI helps you prepare patients, inform them clearly and record conversations. The conversation itself remains your job – and digitalisation gives you the time for it.
Get informed now – with no obligation
Create a digital workflow in your practice too. We will advise you free of charge and with no obligation on your individual case.
Please note that this guide was created for information purposes only, has no legally binding effect and does not constitute legal advice.
FAQs about digital informed consent
Can a consent form be signed digitally?
Yes. The law does not require either a paper form or a handwritten signature. Digitally signed consent forms are permitted and have the same evidential value in court as paper forms. What matters is that the verbal consent discussion takes place and the patient receives a copy of the signed documents.
Can AI replace the consent discussion?
No. Under Section 630e BGB, the patient must be informed verbally by the treating practitioner or a person with the necessary training. AI can prepare the conversation, summarise treatment plans in an understandable way and take over the documentation. Responsibility for the content and completeness of the information always remains with the practitioner.
Is informing patients via video consultation permitted?
Yes, as long as a direct verbal exchange is possible and the patient can ask questions. The legislator considers a video consultation comparable to a face-to-face conversation. By contrast, the BGH only accepts informing patients purely by phone in simple cases.




